Camden News
Publications by New Journal Enterprises
spacer
  Home Archive Competition Jobs Tickets Accommodation Dating Contact us
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
Letters to the Editor
 
No Israeli ‘shoot-to-kill’ policy

The New Journal’s coverage of the inquest into the death of Tom Hurndall in Gaza was very one-sided (‘We will pursue Israeli officers through court’, April 13).
The Israeli soldier who killed Hurndall, Taysir el-Heyb, was from a very poor Israeli-Arab family. He volunteered to join the Israeli army, but only just scraped a pass in the army’s psychology and competence tests. However, they decided to admit him, apparently because of his family’s difficult circumstances and loyalty to the country.
Immediately after the shooting, Taysir phoned his commander, reporting that an armed man was approaching his post and refusing instructions to halt. The commander gave him permission to fire. A few minutes later, he reported that he had shot the man in the head. Taysir also persuaded another Israeli-Arab soldier, Aymad Atawna, to back up this false account.
The authorities initially believed Taysir and Atawna, and thus gave out untrue information. They subsequently carried out a further investigation which led to the prosecution, conviction and imprisonment of both soldiers.
These circumstances do not support the charges of a deliberate policy of the Israeli army to shoot unarmed civilians or of a general lack of control.
The Israeli authorities may have tried too hard to treat fairly a member of a minority. This does not deserve the harsh criticism to which they have been subjected.
Israel is not an outpost of US foreign policy in the Middle East. Had Israel done what the US wanted, it would have left Gaza years ago, Taysir would not have been there and Hurndall would not have been shot. Israel follows its own policies in pursuit of its own objectives, in particular its survival as a safe haven for Jews, who continue to be vilified and victimised in many countries around the world.
JONATHAN, CAROLINE, JACOB,
CAMILLA and GABRIEL TURNER
Shirlock Road
NW3


I fail to follow how the shooting of Tom Hurndall could be referred to as a “group in the Israeli military is out of control” by Sir Gerald Kaufman MP speaking on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme. Another of his cockamamie and crackpot statements.
The offending Sergeant Taysir Hayb has been convicted to eight years for manslaughter, now subject to appeal, when I trust sense will prevail with mercy for a soldier who was acting as he had been trained.
In the heat of conflict, you can’t expect men who have been civilians themselves, when trained as soldiers, and especially in this case as “snipers”, not to shoot to kill.
Tom Hurndall knew what he was getting into and anticipated the risk. He ignored Foreign Office advice to keep away from an unpredictable and dangerous situation where his presence as a photographer could be provocative.
And not dissimilar to an agent provocateur, he was obviously a very brave young man but like many young men in dangerous, exciting situations, with the dedications to a cause, trying to save children, act naively and foolishly thinking it won’t happen to them.
It should be remembered that the Palestinian Militants, who are not in uniform were renowned for encouraging the presence of children in hot-spots of “shooting”, using them as cover, and would like nothing more than an incident where they create an opportunity for a sniper to break cover.
I have sympathy for the Hurndall family; perhaps they can in time instead of dominating their lives with heartache and aggravation, ask themselves – what would Tom have liked them to do as Christians? Support the appeal of the Sergeant Taysir Hayb for mercy and have compassion?
The New Journal is in the wrong in trying to encourage a call for a public outcry, together with Kaufman’s cry for sanctions. It would be far better, together with the Hurndall family, to create and promote a memorial in the name of Tom Hurndall: this could be a sports park or playground to be shared by both Palestinian and Israeli children to help and foster improved relations between the youth looking forward to Peace. I am sure such a project would get support.
S MICHAEL BRECKER
Address supplied


In your editorial comment, you press for the extradition to the UK of those Israeli soldiers responsible for the shooting of Tom Hurndall (Army out of control, April 13).
You describe Israel as an outpost of US’s policy. Israel, like most European, and some Middle-Eastern countries, is an ally of the US. However, Israel’s actions are driven by the defence of its very existence in the face of continued threats to “wipe it out of the face of the earth”.
JACOB BRAUNER
Helenslea Avenue
NW11


Tom Hurndall went to Israeli-occupied Palestine to help Palestinian children who face daily naked aggression from the Israeli army. He was targeted because they knew Tom was helping innocent children and his presence could provide a truthful account of the crimes committed by the Israeli army.
I fully agree with your editorial comment which asks that our government must take the case seriously and not only should Tom Hurndall’s killer be extradited to this country for trial but also those who issued the orders.
I also appreciate Sir Gerald Kaufman MP’s words in daring to openly criticise Israel, urging Israel to abide by international law and international decency.
The New Journal’s skillfully compiled story, covering the inquest last week, shows the Israeli army targeted Tom. It was not the act of one Israeli soldier who fired on Tom but the policy of the “targeted killings” which was practiced.
Dr SALIM HAIDRANI
North Gower Street,
NW1


Send your letters to: The Letters Editor, Camden New Journal, 40 Camden Road, London, NW1 9DR or email to letters@camdennewjournal.co.uk. The deadline for letters is midday Tuesday. The editor regrets that anonymous letters cannot be published, although names and addresses can be withheld. Please include a full name, postal address and telephone number. Letters may be edited for reasons of space.
 
spacer














spacer


Theatre Music
Arts & Events Attractions
spacer
 
 


  up